-
Mortenson’s transition
from climbing bum to
humanitarian hero seems
very abrupt. However,
looking back, it’s clear
that his sense of
mission is rooted in his
childhood, the values of
his parents, and his
relationship with this
sister Christa. Discuss
the various facets of
Mortenson’s character –
the freewheeling
mountain climber, the ER
nurse, the devoted son
and brother, and the
leader of a humanitarian
cause. Do you view him
as continuing the work
his father began? How
did these relationships
contribute to his
humanitarian mission in
Pakistan?
-
What is the significance
of tea in this book and
in the title?
-
Agree or disagree with
Mortenson’s statement:
“When we increase
literacy, we
substantially reduce
tensions.”
-
Describe persons with
whom Mortenson works who
made an impression on
you. What makes them
memorable?
-
Comment on Mortenson’s
decision that CAI
schools should emphasize
increasing girls’
enrollment. “Once you
educate the boys, they
tend to leave the
villages and go in
search for work in the
cities. But girls stay
home, become leaders in
the community, and pass
on what they’ve learned.
If you really want to
change a culture, to
empower women, improve
basic hygiene and health
care, and fight high
rates of infant
mortality, the answer is
to educate girls.”
-
How has this book added
to your understanding of
other cultures and a
geographic region few
Americans have an
opportunity to
experience firsthand?
What information about
the Central Asian region
and culture in this book
did you find most
interesting or
surprising or useful?
-
How does Relin’s telling
the story give it a
different perspective
than if Mortenson had
written the narrative
himself?
-
It has been suggested
that Tara, Mortenson’s
wife, is as much a hero
in her own right as he
is in his. How would you
respond to this comment?
-
Is Mortenson someone you
would like to know? What
questions would you ask
him? What risks has
Mortenson taken? Do you
think he has been brave
or foolish? Mortenson is
shown as a hero but also
as a flawed human being
with some exasperating
traits. Talk about
Mortenson’s character.
Do you think Mortenson
is simply an exceptional
person, or can anyone
make a difference like
this with enough
commitment?
-
There is a telling
passage about
Mortenson’s change of
direction at the start
of the book: “One
evening, he went to bed
by a yak dung fire a
mountaineer who’d lost
his way, and one
morning, by the time
he’d shared a pot of
butter tea with his
hosts and laced up his
boots, he’d become a
humanitarian who’d found
a meaningful path to
follow for the rest of
his life.” What made
Mortenson particularly
ripe for such a
transformation?
-
The Balti people are
fierce yet extremely
hospitable, kind yet
rigid, determined to
better themselves yet
stuck in the past.
Discuss your reactions
to them and the other
groups that Mortenson
tries to help.
-
Mortenson was devastated
when, after returning to
Korphe with supplies to
build a school, village
chief Haji Ali says he
must build a bridge
first. What does
Mortenson learn from
this experience? What
else does he learn from
Haji Ali? What other
“bumps in the road” did
he experience? Discuss
his repeated brushes
with failure and how
they influenced your
opinion of Mortenson and
his efforts.
-
After Haji Ali’s family
saves Greg’s life, he
reflects that he could
never “imagine
discharging the debt he
felt to his hosts in
Korphe.” Discuss this
sense of indebtedness as
key to Mortenson’s
character. Why was
Mortenson compelled to
return to the region
again and again? In your
opinion, does he repay
his debt by the end of
the book?
-
References to paradise
run throughout the book
– Mortenson’s childhood
home in Tanzania, the
mountain scenery, even
Berkeley, California,
are all referred to as
“paradises.” Discuss the
concept of paradise,
lost and regained, and
how it influences
Mortenson’s mission. The
book also states “the
Balti held the key to a
kind of uncomplicated
happiness that was
disappearing in the
developing world.” This
peaceful simplicity of
life seems to be part of
what attracts Mortenson
to the villagers.
Discuss the pros and
cons of bringing
“civilization” to the
mountain community.
-
“I expected something
like this from an
ignorant village mullah,
but to get those kinds
of letters from my
fellow Americans made me
wonder whether I should
just give up.” Mortenson
remarked after he
started getting hate
mail in the wake of
September 11. What was
your reaction to the
letters Mortenson
received? How would you
have reacted to such
mail?
-
Why do you think the
villages in Korphe were
so excited about getting
their own school? What
is unique about having a
school, as opposed to
other things Mortenson
could have built, like a
hospital or community
center?
-
How is building schools
in Pakistan similar to
climbing a mountain?
What did Mortenson learn
from his failed attempt
to summit K2?
-
Much of the book is a
meditation on what it
means to be a foreigner
assimilating with
another culture. Discuss
your own experience with
foreign cultures –
things that you have
learned, mistakes you
have made, and
misunderstandings you
have endured. In what
ways does Mortenson
adapt to Muslim culture?
What’s your reaction to
this? What different
reactions did (or might)
his adaptations provide
within the Muslim
community?
-
Did the book change your
views toward Islam or
Muslims? Consider the
cleric Syed Abbas, and
also the cleric who
called a fatwa on
Mortenson. Syed Abbas
implores Americans to
“look into our hearts
and see that the great
majority of us are not
terrorists, but good and
simple people.” Discuss
this statement. Has the
book inspired you to
learn more about the
region? After reading
Three Cups of Tea, are
you optimistic about
peace in Pakistan and
Afghanistan?
-
In this book is a
powerful but simple
political message: we
each as individuals have
the power to change the
world, one cup of tea at
a time. What do you
think of the “one cup of
tea at a time”
philosophy? Do you think
Mortenson’s vision can
work for lasting and
meaningful change? Does
what Mortenson and the
Central Asian Institute
do help the global image
of the United States?
Why or why not?
-
Thousands of madrassas
offer free room and
board and education in
areas the Pakistani’s
educational system does
not reach. Of the 2
million Pakistani
students taught in
various madrassas, over
eighty thousand become
Taliban recruits. Should
schools remain
politically and
religiously neutral? Can
they be? Can this
situation be compared to
other historical events?
-
It seems as if
everywhere Mortenson
turns he has to deal
with politics. What are
some of the political
obstacles (local,
regional, global) he had
to overcome? What does
his experience tell us
about the relationship
between politics and
education? Does this
happen in the United
States? In Texas? In
Richardson?
-
What critical questions
should we ask about
philanthropic projects
such as those described
in this book?
-
At the heart of Three
Cups of Tea is a simple
message: education is
important. Reflect on
your own education. How
has it mattered to you?
What might your future
be like if you were
limited to the education
available to most in
Pakistan and
Afghanistan? Why is
higher education -
especially in our
society – important?
-
Other people constantly
impact Mortenson’s
ability to carry out his
plans. What role does
“community” (other
people, relationships,
etc.) play in his
experience? What
specific events or
scenes in the book
demonstrate how other
help (or hinder) his
work? According to Three
Cups of Tea, how does
Mortenson characterize
the concept of
community? What is the
relationship of the
individual to his sense
of community? As an
individual, what
specific steps might you
be willing to take to
meet the challenges
posed by this book? In
other words, what next
steps are you willing to
take?
Questions adapted from
the following sources:
Plainfield Public
Library/Reading Across
Plainfield; Washington
State
University/Vancouver;
about.com; University of
Missouri; Penguin
Reading Guide